Class Notes: 9/3/2026

The book of Romans part 423 Rom 9:20 ;

https://youtu.be/dgQyog_sny0

In our verse-by-verse study of Romans we are at the first phrase of Rom 9:20 that in the NASB reads; "On the contrary who are you O man who answers back to God."

When we stopped last time we were noting Pharaoh's negative volition and how God was using it to evangelize the known world because while Pharaoh because of his scar tissue of soul was saying, "no" many Egyptians, Ethiopians and Jews who were under his authority were saying, "yes" to the gospel.

But at the same time Pharaoh's hardness of heart produced arrogance, and arrogance produced impudence that rejected God's authority.

When a person becomes so arrogant from scar tissue of the soul that he is divorced from truth, inevitably that rejection of reality means the rejection of legitimate authority.

Rejection of legitimate authority results on social fragmentation and national degeneration. We see this in our country and in the world today.

If God chooses to harden Pharaoh's heart He has a just and righteous reason that is compatible with His perfect integrity to do it. He has perfect integrity and therefore He is perfectly fair and just; so He is always fair to everyone.

Consequently, no one has a right to make any accusations against God but if they do their Impudence may cause God to take advantage of it as He did in the case of Pharaoh.

Pharaoh used his own negative volition to build scar tissue of the soul that the Lord God responded to with the demonstration of His power and that demonstration evangelized the world.

We see from this that God uses people's evil negative volition to advance His plan.

Pharaoh's free will expressed negative volition on six occasions prior to the scriptural statement that "God hardened his heart." Pharaoh had individual freedom from his own self-determination. He was not only a free agent but as the king of Egypt he was a sovereign free agent so he had virtually unlimited freedom to choose.

Paul finds himself facing similar irrational opposition from the Jews in his own generation and we see this same thing in the world today. Paul is comparing the evil negative volition of the Jews of his generation to the irrational evil negative volition of Gentile ruler of Egypt who the Jews hated.

The physical or racial descendants of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob erroneously assumed that spiritual heritage was based on physical birth. Their error was in not understanding that spiritual birth was actually the predicate for spiritual heritage.

Therefore it is the spiritual descendants of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob that are also biological descendants who believe in Jesus Christ who are the exclusive recipients of the unconditional promises and the covenants of God to Israel.

To enjoy the spiritual heritage of Israel requires the imputation of God's judicial righteousness and eternal life. Only those Jews who believed in the Lord Jesus Christ, the God of Israel, will have the promised heritage of Israel.

Only the arrogant impudence of the unregenerate Jews would answer back and contradict God's perfect plan so Paul directly challenges the legalistic Jewish unbelievers, the Judaisers who were only Abraham's biological descendants and not his spiritual descendants on the basis of faith in Jesus Christ.

Rom 9:20; In the NASB the next phrase is "the thing will not say to the molder." In the Greek Paul's quotation starts with the negative adverb "mh" (not), that used in a question that expects a negative answer. The other Greek negative for not is "ou" or "ouk" that denies a fact.

The negative adverb "mh" (not) denies the idea behind the fact. Next we have "eipo" that is the future active indicative of "lego" (will say). "Lego" (say) is used to describe conversation, shouting, screaming, giving orders, communicating or talking.

With the not we will translated it, "shall not say." It is in the deliberative future tense where uncertainty is expressed about a future event. The active voice: the creature generally produces the action of the verb (speaking out) but not always.

The interrogative indicative takes the viewpoint of reality that is implied as a fact. The negative "mh" (not) indicates that the question is rhetorical so it is a facet of the debater's technique that Paul is using in this passage.

The subject is the nominative singular from the noun "plasma" (molded). It refers to what is being created, formed or molded. Plasma is commonly used to describe the product of an artist, like the potter making a pot, a cup or a dish so we translate this as, "Can what is molded say."

Then we have the aorist active participle from "plasso" (plasma), that is the ascriptive use of the participle that describes a noun that belongs to a general category of artists such as potters.

The definite article "ho" (its) in the dative singular is an indirect object that is used as a possessive pronoun so we translate it "to its molder."

"Why did you make me like this?" This phrase begins with the nominative neuter singular from the interrogative pronoun "tis" (why)." This is an interrogative of impudence. The aorist active indicative of "poieo (make) means to make, to create or manufacture.

The constantive aorist tense refers to the completed action of the verb. The active voice describes the subject (the pot of clay) as producing the action of the verb and by analogy it refers to the arrogant and unbelieving Jewish people of Paul's day as producing the action of the verb by questioning God's integrity for what He is doing.

Again the indicative mood is interrogative because it assumes that there is an actual fact that can be used in answer to the question. The accusative singular direct object is "ego" (me).

The adverb "houtos" (like this) describes an event that occurred in the past. This describes the principle that arrogance plus impudence results in blasphemy.

Expanded Translation Rom 9:20; "On the contrary, O mankind, you, who are you who answers back to the God? Can what is molded say to its molder, why have you made me like this?"

This rhetorical question is a debater's technique that is used to emphasize the blasphemy of the Jews who rely on their own ability from natural birth, and their biological relationship to Abraham, rather than God's grace blessing of spiritual birth that had actually been the reason that Abraham had an eternal relationship with God on the basis of faith alone. Gen 15:6;

It was God's grace that made Abraham, Isaac and Jacob great not their biological physical heritage.

God's integrity is not subject to contradiction or impudence because God is totally, eternally, and infinitely fair. It is impossible for God to be unfair or arbitrary, or even inconsistent because of His perfect character.

Therefore in perfect righteousness God's justice provided man with a free will, so that man is a free agent in determining his own destiny. That means man must take the responsibility for his own free will decisions. Taking responsibility for one's self is the basic standard for establishing maturity.

Therefore man cannot blame his own mistakes and errors on perfect and incorruptible God. When God chooses to reject, pardon, or punish whom He pleases, He does so on the basis of His perfect integrity that is based on His righteousness and His justice or holiness.

Arrogant arbitrary subjective mankind assumes that God is the same as he is so he projects his own subjectivity on God but mankind cannot legitimately try to superimpose his own weakness and unfairness on God because God is perfect.

Man's objection to the inequalities of time as well as eternity is really an objection to the fact the he possesses freedom and the right of self-determination that produces the very inequalities that he blames God for.

Furthermore, when man objects to the printout of election, foreordination and foreknowledge or wrath. He fails to realize that his own free volition is what determines his own situation.

Negative volition seeks to circumvent condemnation from God's justice by blaming God's omniscience for entering only the facts into His decree in eternity past.

Man's irresponsibility and depravity is never more dramatically portrayed than when he tries to blame God for his own thoughts, decisions and actions.

God is not obligated to save the reversionistic unbeliever nor is He obligated to bless the reversionistic believer because their situation is the product of their own reversionism from their free will rejection of God's grace.

God is not obligated to impute blessing to the reversionistic believer in time, nor to impute rewards to him at the judgment seat of Christ.

God is obligated to Himself and God is obligated to His grace policy. God does not make exceptions for people because they are nice or have sweet personalities or are sincere or kind.

The issue is God's attitude toward Jesus Christ, the living Word of God, and after salvation, His attitude toward Bible, the written Word of God that is Jesus' thinking that comprises Bible doctrine.

An attitude that comes from man's volition rather than God's sovereignty is the desire is to blame God.

God must be consistent with Himself so He must punish the unbeliever and save the believer. He must bless the mature believer and discipline the reversionistic believer because God is always fair to everyone.

No one can say to God, "Why have you made me this way?" because mankind has his own free will so he made himself this way. Man is a free agent so he has self-determination. So the answer to Paul's rhetorical question is obviously "NOT!"

Mankind under the influence of Satanic thinking is always trying to force God to conform to his subjective human thinking rather than accepting God in terms of God's revelation. Man is always trying to bend God to his own thinking and saying, that "This is God's will."

The quotation from Isaiah 29:16; that Isaiah applied to the entire nation of Israel, Paul applies to the individual person.

Paul combines the doctrine of God's perfect integrity with the reality of man's arrogant subjectivity and his ignorance to establish the true issue of omniscience feeding facts and only the facts into God's decree.

Paul is not directing his remarks to the elect or the foreordained that attain spiritual maturity but in context he is speaking to the condemned Jew, who has rejected Christ as savior, has refused God's Shekinah glory, and is now grasping at straws in an attempt to justify his own failures.

To blaspheme and malign the perfect wisdom and justice of God is the irrational act of a desperate person. Irrational because after having made hundreds of free will decisions, culminating in judgment, God is blamed and maligned in an attempt to shift their responsibility for their own bad decisions to God by blaming God's sovereignty that simply ratified their free will decisions.


Paul uses debater's technique to refute this blasphemy shift the responsibility right back to human free will where free negative volition has manufactured hardness of heart.

Rom 9:21; begins with a disjunctive conjunction "e" (or) that is used in interrogative sentences to introduce and present a rhetorical question. It is simply translated "or" but it actually introduces an interrogative debater's finesse that takes the principle of the previous verse and illustrates the verse from the obvious.

Even the most ignorant person is aware of the fact that the inanimate pot doesn't argue with the potter. The nominative singular subject is "kerameus" (potter). This was a person who in the ancient world was very important because he made all kinds of useful utensils.

The next word is the negative adverb "ouk" (not) that is used in rhetorical questions expecting a positive answer of yes. In the Greek "mh" (not) expects a negative answer; "ouk" (not) expects a positive answer.

The answer to this question is "yes," because of the use of "ouk." You do not translate it "no," you translate it "yes." Only the Greeks would invent such a system of syntax so we have so far: "Or does not the potter."

Next we have the present active indicative of "echo" (have) that means to have or to possess. The customary present denotes what habitually occurs or may be reasonably expected to occur.

The active voice: the potter produces the action of the verb. The indicative mood is an interrogative indicative that assumes that there is an actual fact that can be stated in answer to the question that has escaped the brilliant Jews who are objecting to Paul and opposing him in his debate. Paul is going to finesse them right out of their minds.

The next word is the accusative singular direct object from "exousia" (right or authority) it means authority over, power over or right so far we have "Or does not the potter possess authority."

Then we have the genitive of relationship from "pelos" (wet clay). In the analogy God is the potter and mankind is the clay. When compared to God, mankind is completely and totally ignorant.

The rhetorical question expects a positive answer so it focuses attention on God's authority as the creator of all things including mankind and the universe.

Next we have the preposition "ek" (from) plus the ablative from the attributive use of the intensive pronoun autos (the same)- "from the same."

This is followed by the ablative singular from the noun "phurama" (mixture). It is derived from the verb phurao that means to mix. What was mixed or mingled was called phurama. Phurao comes first because what is to be mixed comes before the mixture that comes from what is mixed.

So we have the prepositional phrase "ek tou autou phurama, that is translated "from the same mixture."

The potter came before the pot. To mix and to mold and to manufacture takes something more than being manufactured. It takes more to make than it does to be made. With this is the aorist active infinitive of the verb "poieo" (make) or to manufacture.

The constantive aorist tense describes action that is extended over a period of time. The constantive aorist describes the action of the verb in its entirety so the entire history of the human race from beginning to end is in view.

© Copyright 2026, Michael Lemmon Bible Ministries. World Rights Reserved.